How to Raise Capital in a Trust Recession with Todd Heitner, Ep. 786

Todd Heitner has spent roughly 20 years helping real estate investors improve their online presence, with the last decade focused on multifamily apartments and syndication. After seeing capital raisers struggle not because they lacked tools, but because they lacked strategy, Todd expanded from providing websites and ready-made marketing assets into helping syndicators attract investors more effectively. His current focus includes leveraging other people’s audiences, improving investor-facing strategy, and using AI in ways that build trust instead of eroding it.

Make sure to download our free guide, 7 Questions Every Passive Investor Should Ask, here.

Key Takeaways

• Understand why today’s capital-raising environment is harder because investors are operating in a broader “trust recession”

• Avoid cold outreach tactics that feel transactional and instead build trust through warmer, more personal connections

• Learn how to leverage other people’s audiences so you can borrow trust instead of trying to manufacture it from scratch

• Identify a specific investor audience you actually understand, rather than targeting people only because they have money

• Use AI to speed up research and content creation, but only with clear strategy and human review so your message still sounds like you

Topics

Why We’re in a Trust Recession

• Todd explains that businesses across industries are facing a harder trust environment, driven by institutional distrust, scams, fake reviews, AI-generated noise, and marketing overload

• He notes that multifamily syndication has been hit especially hard because many investors have recently been burned by bad deals, paused distributions, capital calls, and losses

What Not to Do When Raising Capital

• Cold outreach that jumps straight into a pitch does not work well, especially in the current environment

• Todd gives examples like random LinkedIn pitches, old acquaintances suddenly asking for money, and generic outreach that tries to force trust before a relationship exists

How to Build Trust More Effectively

• Instead of pitching immediately, Todd recommends leading with genuine interest in the other person and having a normal conversation first

• If the fit is there, the discussion can move naturally toward what you’re working on without making the interaction feel forced or transactional

Why Warm Referrals Matter

• Todd compares warm referrals to getting a restaurant recommendation from a trusted friend: the guard comes down faster because trust is borrowed from the person making the introduction

• He explains that syndicators should think carefully about who their ideal investors already trust and then create win-win ways to access those audiences

Leveraging Other People’s Audiences

• Todd shares an example from a multifamily event where simply being introduced as a speaker changed the context completely and created a line of people ready to talk to him afterward

• The main lesson is that context matters: when someone trusted introduces you, people approach you differently than when you chase them cold

Choosing the Right Investor Audience

• Todd says syndicators need to know exactly who they are targeting, rather than taking a broad “anyone with money” approach

• He uses doctors as an example, explaining that once you know your audience, you can identify the podcasts, professionals, events, and communities they already trust

• He also warns that if you do not understand an audience’s actual problems, pains, and context, your message will not resonate and may even reduce trust

How to Reach Out Credibly

• Todd recommends personalized outreach that starts with the other person, not with yourself

• He says the strongest messages make it obvious that they were written specifically for one person, explain why the outreach matters to that person, and make a simple ask

• If a message could be sent to 100 different people without changing a word, Todd says it is not good enough

Using AI the Right Way

• Todd believes AI can be powerful for capital raisers, especially for content creation, research, and identifying connections, but only if the operator already has a clear process and strategy

• He warns that using AI without strategy just creates bad or generic content faster

• He specifically emphasizes that AI-generated content must still sound like you, and that users should never hand everything off blindly without review

📢 Announcement: Learn about our Apartment Investing Mastermind here.

Round of Insights

• Failure that set Todd up for success: Not recognizing the importance of partnerships and relationships early in his single-family business. Watching a competitor dominate through stronger relationships pushed Todd to make partnerships a core focus, and those relationships are still producing referrals years later.
• Digital or mobile resource: Claude.
• Book recommendation: How to Get Everything You Can Out of All You’ve Got by Jay Abraham.
• Daily habit: Journaling with a structured routine. Todd rates different areas of his life on a scale of 1 to 5, then identifies what’s missing to make each one a 5 so he knows what to focus on next.
• #1 insight for building trust in relationships: Focus on the other person. Understand what they care about, what problem you can solve, and what value you can provide — relationships grow naturally from there.
• Favorite restaurant in Pennsylvania: Boxers.

Next Steps

• Check out https://apartmentinvestorpro.com/ to learn more about Todd’s work.

• Audit your current investor outreach and remove any messaging that feels cold, generic, or overly transactional

• Define a narrower ideal investor profile that you actually understand and can speak to credibly

• Identify the people, platforms, and professionals your target audience already trusts, then look for ways to access those audiences through warm introductions or partnerships

• Review how you are using AI and make sure it is supporting a clear strategy rather than generating generic content faster

• Personalize your outreach so it starts with the other person, not with your own pitch

Thank you for joining us for another great episode! If you’re enjoying the show, please LEAVE A RATING OR REVIEW, and be sure to hit that subscribe button so you don’t miss an episode.